Showing posts with label New American. Show all posts
Showing posts with label New American. Show all posts

Thursday, March 18, 2010

WOODFIRE GRILL

She says:
Oh Kevin Gillespie, how do we love thee? Let me count the ways…

  • We love you for solidifying Atlanta’s place on America’s gastronomic map through your amazing performance on Top Chef.
  • We love you for centering your restaurant’s fare on local, sustainable, organic food and humanly-treated animals.
  • We love you for being insanely sweet and humble even though you are totally famous.
  • We love you for putting bacon in everything, even your desserts.
  • We love you for indulging our doe-eyed admiration, for taking a picture with us, and even signing our menu!

But mostly, we love you for your cooking. After months of anticipation, we finally ate at Woodfire Grill this past weekend. Our expectations were high. We weren’t disappointed.

He says:
After much hemming and hawing and deliberating with our excellent waiter, who assured Uptown Girl the red meat dishes could be substituted for vegetarian ones, we opted for the five course chef’s tasting menu. Apparently it changes every night, and even from hour to hour, depending on the ingredients available, so we were completely at Kevin’s mercy.

A bite-size pimento cheese profiterole started things off. The pastry crust was flaky and buttery, but the cheese filling of this amuse bouche lacked nuance.

Fortunately the sliced raw scallops that followed were excellent. They were incredibly silky, and the lemon oil and pink pepper added just the right amount of zing. A stellar peekytoe crab salad completed the dish.

The second course of sautéed California morels was even better. Fungi of this caliber can change the way you think about mushrooms. They were remarkably earthy and smoky, and further enriched by a roasted chicken glace. A huge dollop of duck foie gras mousse threw off the balance of this dish, but after I spooned half of it aside, the resulting union of fat and mushrooms was splendid.

She says:
I was impressed to learn that the artisanal foie gras was “cruelty-free” (rather than force-feeding the animals, they are kept in an environment of constantly available food to fatten them up). Even so, I opted out. Kevin supplied me with a perfectly cooked risotto with morel mushrooms and broccoli. Although rich in all the right ways, the most noticeable characteristic of this dish was the freshness and intensity of the veggies.

He says:
Every great meal has a standout dish, one that you will recall years later because it redefines that what a chef can achieve. For me, Kevin’s slow-roasted pork belly was that dish. Glistening with fat, it melted on the tongue in all its buttery perfection.

The spiced lamb wasn’t quite as marvelous but it was much more inventive. Accompanied by tandoori yogurt, lentil sauce, and a tomato-ginger-cauliflower and potato mash, it’s Indian home cooking masquerading as a fine dining entrée. And plenty fine it was, with spicy and cool notes mingling with the gamy lamb.

She says:
My vegetarian entrée just happened to be the same one that Kevin used to win the vegetarian challenge on Top Chef! A mix of potatoes, Hen of the Woods, and morel mushrooms were prepared on the woodfire grill. Each head of the Hen of the Woods clusters were grilled to a slight crisp, and they paired beautifully with the smokiness of the sautéed greens. A smear of a tangy cream sauce cut the saltiness and rounded it all out.

Dessert consisted of a dense tres leches banana cake topped with three wallops of chocolate mousse and a thin bar of milk chocolate. Next to the cake was a banana sorbet. The sorbet, only mildly sweetened and sprinkled with marcona almonds and sea salt, provided a needed contrast to the sweet cake. Overall, it was a very well balanced dessert.

We say:
Woodfire Grill ranks among the top restaurants in Atlanta. Most dishes were very good, and several were spectacular. In Atlanta’s fine dining scene it is second only to Bacchanalia. And did we mention that we love Kevin Gillespie?





Woodfire Grill
1782 Cheshire Bridge Road
Atlanta, GA 30324

Sunday, September 20, 2009

ECCO

She says:
I’m mulling over the meal Downtown Boy and I had last week at Ecco during Midtown Restaurant Week, trying to capture the essence of our uninspiring dining experience. “Ecco… Ecco…” I repeat to myself. And then it strikes me: Ecco is perfectly named (albeit misspelled). It is a restaurant repeating something good, something strong and original, but is merely a reverberation, an act of mimicry, an echo, if you will, of better restaurants.

The interior has a classical touch of old Europe, which is appropriate for the “seasonally-inspired European cuisine” they serve (according to our waiter), but it mostly aims for the modern sophistication of newer restaurants with its open kitchen, long bar, and dim lighting. It’s a ubiquitous look, and if you’ve eaten at any upscale New American restaurant in the past year, then you’ve been here before.

He says:
The perpetual sense of déjà vu continues straight into the menu. The oak-grilled asparagus, drizzled in olive oil, has a nice smokiness but otherwise tastes exactly like the asparagus you cooked last night in your own kitchen.

The roasted organic chicken tastes, like, well, chicken. The breasts are well roasted and moist, but the salsa verde blanketing the chicken doesn’t add enough oomph to make this dish stand out.

Fortunately the steelhead is more interesting. This Atlantic trout is highly reminiscent of salmon due to its similar river/ocean life cycle. It is beautifully grilled, and the braised celery provides an earthy contrast to the dish’s overall butteriness.

She says: For me, the most original item was the fried goat cheese. The small balls of fried cheese have a salty outer shell, and are dipped in honey and sprinkled with black pepper. It provides a full symphony of flavors.

The chocolate terrine is like many other decadently rich flourless chocolate cakes, but I wasn’t complaining. Some things don’t need inspiration. It comes with large chunks of nut brittle that give the dish an interesting textural contrast, if not a break from the sweetness. For better or worse, I polished it off, while poor Downtown Boy reveled in his own skewed sense of dessert heaven, raving about the mushy bread pudding thing he was spooning up.

He says:
Oh dear. According to Uptown Girl, if it ain’t chocolate, it ain’t dessert. I liked my sour cherry bread pudding just fine. Like the chocolate terrine, it was a serviceable if unremarkable dessert.

We say:
Most people will like Ecco. The food is solid, and it’s a perfectly nice restaurant that won’t leave a hole in your wallet. But whenever we go we can’t help but get the feeling we’ve eaten these unoriginal dishes – in better incarnations – before.




Ecco
40 7th Street NE, Atlanta, GA 30308
http://www.ecco-atlanta.com/index.htm

Friday, May 29, 2009

THE GREEN GODDESS


She says:
After the “wisdom” of numerous Yelpers led us to three unsuccessful Cajun meals in a row in New Orleans, Downtown Boy and I were ready for something different. That’s when we stumbled upon the Green Goddess, a 4-day old restaurant nestled in a cute alleyway in the middle of the French Quarter. Ironically, although the menu utterly lacked in fried seafood, alligator meat, and anything else Cajun, it turned out to be the best meal of our trip!

The eager-to-please waiter easily convinced me to try the “Spooky” blue corn crepes, purely on the intrigue of the dish’s mysterious ingredient, huitlacoche, a rare Atzec corn fungus. Considered a delicacy in Mexico, in the States we apparently throw this “corn smut” out like any old fungus. This is a huge mistake! Delicate blue corn tortillas were piled with the mushroom-like fungus and covered with a brandy ragout, all of the flavors coming together to form an earthy, complex, slightly bitter, and completely addictive dish.

He says:
The bangers and mash was a delightful twist on the English pub standard. The duck sausage was hearty and bold, and it contrasted wonderfully with the butter and citrus notes of the sweet potato mash. And to think this little gem cost the same as those wretched po boys I suffered at the two Masperos!

The best part of the meal might have been the coffee, though. I have a soft spot for coffee mixed with condensed milk, which is how my mom used to make it. Throw in some chicory root for added depth and you’ve got the perfect ending to a meal.

She says:
After such an impressive entrée, I couldn’t resist trying the strawberry crème brulee for dessert. The burnt sugar atop had been soaked in balsamic vinegar and made for a delicious coating. The crème brulee itself had an excellent strawberry flavor though the consistency was a bit too yogurt-like.

We say:
If you’re a budget traveler in New Orleans, the Green Goddess is a godsend.




The Green Goddess

307 Exchange Alley, New Orleans, LA

Thursday, March 26, 2009

TILTH

She says:
Tilth is the kind of restaurant that you still talk about years after dining there.

Our dinner at this Seattle newcomer was a highly anticipated event. Ever since Frank Bruni, the New York Times food critic, selected Tilth as one of the top 10 new restaurants in America in 2008, Downtown Boy has been pining to go. I was also eager to eat at a restaurant committed to using only local, organic ingredients, which is exemplified both by its name (“tilth” refers to nutrient-rich soil) and the fact that it is one of only two restaurants in the country to receive organic certification from Oregon Tilth. Housed (literally) in the renovated first floor of a small Wallingford home, Tilth accommodates only 40 people at a time. This charming intimacy is enhanced by the waitstaff, who offer intelligent advice about the menu. Our waitress helpfully pointed out that it was common for guests to strategically order several half-dishes to maximize the number of entrees they could try. This is just what we did.

He says:
The simply-named "Hor d'Oeuvres" appetizer was anything but -- rather, it was simply marvelous. A gumdrop-sized ball of homemade mascarpone cheese sat on a crisp parmesan cracker, garnished with a fresh slice of fig. The ensuing synthesis of creamy, salty, and sweet notes had the entire table breaking into spontaneous smiles. This might have been the finest appetizer I've ever had.

My first half-entree, the smoked heirloom bean cassoulet, was surprisingly excellent. A bean stew rarely gets me excited, but Tilth's version came with wild mushrooms, truffles, and oven-dried tomatoes. An incredible, smoky earthiness infused every bite of this dish -- I never imagined such intensity could be wrung from such humble ingredients. The rich porcine flavors of my second entree, the slow-cooked pork cheek, were less unexpected but just as wonderful. The chefs at Tilth have mastered pork, retaining its subtle gaminess and keeping it tender enough to split with a fork. I mopped up every last piece in the pancetta-parmesan broth.

Last but not least came the Alaskan sablefish, a type of cod, which had been cooked sous vide. For those who do not know, the sous vide method allows for pressurized cooking at very low temperatures, which preserves the delicate texture of meat. For me, Tilth sets the standard for this kind of culinary magic. My first bite of sablefish literally melted on my tongue. My second bite, accompanied by a fennel salad and picholine olives, was even better. At this point, I was becoming convinced that this restaurant could do no wrong.

She says:
I agree, that sablefish was incredible. My other favorite, as odd as it sounds, was the cauliflower flan. The truffled flan was so rich you'd never guess that it was made from cauliflower. Drizzled on the side was a puree with meyer lemon, capers, and tarragon. I have seen many restaurants use artsy drizzles of sauces or purees to make their dishes appear fancy, but these usually don't add much to the dish. On the contrary, this puree provided a tart contrast to the creamy flan. In fact, each bite got progressively better as the various flavors fused on my tongue.

Less noteworthy was the sockeye salmon tartare. It's not that the mixture of raw salmon (of the quality you only find in the Pacific Northwest) with cornichon, endive, and dijon wasn't delicious ... it was just less impressive than the sablefish and flan.

As we ordered desserts, our waitress once again came to the rescue, insisting with surprising assertiveness that we include the cheesecake. Her advice was spot-on. It was unlike any other cheesecake I have seen or tasted... far less sweet, with the freshness of the cheese standing out. The little balls of sweet fromage blanc sitting atop a tiny crust of feuilletine had us all fighting over the final bites. We also had to try the avocado mousse, for novelty sake. I don't think it'll be replacing chocolate mousse anytime soon, but once again the unique combination of fluffy, lightly-sweetened mousse, candied ginger, and cilantro syrup had our palettes spinning.

He says:
The cheesecake was indeed on its own level of awesomeness. The almond brown butter cake paled in comparison -- it was too plain -- but the blood orange creme brulee held its own. Uptown Girl found it too sweet, but the rest of us swooned over the candied citrus rinds and silky custard.

We say:
Many other restaurants focus on local, seasonal fare, but Tilth takes it to new heights. With startling flavor combinations and top-notch service, Tilth is truly one of the best restaurants in America. We can't imagine having a better meal this year.




Tilth
1411 N 45th St, Seattle, WA 98103
tilthblog.wordpress.com

Friday, February 20, 2009

4TH & SWIFT

He says:
This past weekend, I treated Uptown Girl to a special Valentine’s Day dinner at 4th & Swift, one of Atlanta’s hottest new restaurants in 2008. And what says “romance” more than a 4-course prix fixe menu for $75/person? With Bacchanalia-level prices, though, there also come the expectation of a creative menu, top-shelf ingredients, and unexpected pairings that challenge the palette.

Could 4th & Swift deliver?

She says:
For the first course, Downtown Boy and I both chose the poached Maine lobster. If they were going to charge us an arm and a leg for dinner, we were going to get the most out of it! They were generous with the lobster meat, which was buttery and delicious. It came atop a pile of cauliflower “risotto,” which was, unfortunately, just a bland pile of steamed cauliflower. Also absent was the carrot-ginger emulsion… there was a butter sauce on the bottom of the plate, but it lacked any distinct ginger or carrot flavor.

My second course involved Yellowfin tuna prepared two ways. The first, a slab of tuna lightly seared and set on top of seaweed salad, was uninventive. The second was tastier and more creative – a spicy tuna tartare mixed with avocado and topped with wasabi tobiko (roe).

He says:
My second appetizer of pork sugo and herb gnocchi was disappointing. Ground up into a Bolognese-style ragu, the pork was as bland as the tomato base it came with. It didn’t help that underneath the parmesan flakes it looked like Hamburger Helper. The accompanying gnocchi was delicate and tasty, but it wasn’t enough to save this dish.

My “counting sheep” entrée – a North African inspired dish that included 3 types of mutton – fared much better. The merguez (spicy sausage) was rich and smoky. Two generous chops came with a creamy tahini sauce. And the slow braised shoulder, while tame, paired well with the moist bed of couscous and a spicy harissa.

She says:
On our server’s recommendation, I selected the roasted North Carolina pheasant for my entree. It reminded me of Thanksgiving dinner. First, the late fall/winter flavors were all there… the tender roasted pheasant meat, the buttery mashed sweet potatoes, the cabbage hash, and a sort of cranberry and nut chutney. And second, it was far too much food. I definitely enjoyed the dish, but I also wondered if 4th and Swift was trying to justify the price of this prix fixe meal through quantity rather than quality.

Consequently I could only manage a few bites of my dessert, a spiced chocolate pot de crème. The custard was fine, but missing any real intensity. I was put off by the cinnamon “churros” that came alongside, as they were not cooked through, leaving the interior unappetizingly gooey.

He says:
The parsnip and apple cake, 4th and Swift’s avant garde version of carrot cake, was a complete letdown. Any notes of either parsnip or apple were lost in two successive layers of maple cream cheese frosting.

Another letdown, I might add, was the restaurant’s décor. The entire “faux warehouse” look of backlit brick face walls and exposed piping is just so played out. It’s the de facto look of restaurants that are too lazy to create an authentic vibe. And I guess that’s my major problem with 4th & Swift, overall. The kitchen here is talented, but too many dishes are lazily prepared, or formulaic, or just plain boring.

We say:
Good food in search of true inspiration.




4th & Swift

621 North Avenue NE, Atlanta, GA 30308
http://www.4thandswift.com/

Thursday, December 18, 2008

BACCHANALIA

Original Post: May 2007

He says:
Ever since coming to Atlanta, Uptown Girl and I have been in search of a truly excellent restaurant. We’ve been to beautiful bistros with awful entrees and ugly diners with wonderful comfort food, but we still had not found that one place that could execute a creative, elegant dining experience from start to finish.

Enter Bacchanalia.

We’d heard about this restaurant from several sources, like Atlanta magazine and Citysearch, where it perennially tops the fine dining lists. But the label “Best restaurant in Atlanta” is thrown around far too loosely these days, and we’ve been burned one too many times to trust such sources. My parents were visiting Atlanta for the first time, however, so I figured we might as well give Bacchanalia a shot. I’m glad we did.

She says:
I will say up front that Bacchanalia is fabulous. The food (which we will get to in a moment) is clearly the star of this culinary show, with the setting and service merely there to highlight it. The restaurant is elegant and unimposing, with one window-filled wall providing a direct view into the bright and bustling kitchen. The wait staff, dressed in white tunics and black pants, appears purely utilitarian, almost stoic, and delivers impeccable service.

Of course, when we set out to Bacchanalia, we didn’t know quite what we were getting into. In other words, we weren’t expecting the $72/person prix fixe menu (sans wine). Fortunately, with a party of four ordering a different dish at each of the four courses, I can confidently say that we tasted much of what Bacchanalia has to offer.

Or should I say had to offer, considering that the menu changes frequently. Bacchanalia’s menu is comprised completely of seasonal, organic ingredients, much of which actually comes from the farm of chef duo Anne Quatrano and Clifford Harrison.

He says:
The quality of Bacchanalia’s ingredients came through right away in the appetizers. The pickled wild ramp risotto was creamy and indulgent, the Gulf white shrimp particularly savory. And the gulf crab fritter was marvelous, by far the finest crab cake I have ever tasted. The exterior is flash-fried so that it yields with a touch of the fork, and the shredded crab within is so fresh it actually reminded me of the open ocean.

She says:
I agree… the crab fritter was possibly the best dish of the entire meal. Unlike many other crab cakes, there is little filler to drown out the crab meat. It has a Thai pepper “essence” that makes it slightly sweet, slightly spicy, and completely delicious. My least favorite appetizer was the California snails… they seemed bland in comparison to the vivid flavors of the other appetizers.

For the main course, Downtown Boy’s mom and I avoided the red meat and shared the Florida black grouper and cured duck breast. The grouper was the best of all our entrees. It was cooked to perfection… the delicate white meat seared just enough to leave the outside slightly crispy. The accompanying artichokes, rainbow chard, and fennel were so tasty that I saved them for my last bite. The duck breast was also good, but again, the accompaniments (wild onions, morel mushrooms, and ramp broth) really brought the flavor. It goes to show that using local, seasonal ingredients makes a huge difference.

He says:
The pan-roasted lamb loin I ordered was tender but a bit too polite for my taste. Red meat should be unruly and bloody, and Bacchanalia’s pretty, slender medallions were not at the same level as that excellent black grouper. The same went for the prime tenderloin; it was tame when it should have been adventurous. Additionally, the roasted marrow served with it was a flavorless spoonful of melted fat, which left us all rather puzzled. All this said, both my father and I cleaned our plates.

She says:
While I didn’t taste the lamb or tenderloin, I think one of Bacchanalia’s strengths is the subtle complexities of its dishes. This does not translate into the “unruly and bloody” meat you might find at a steakhouse, but rather the quiet undertones of garlic and onion imparted to duck by ramp broth.

Next we moved to the “cheese and contrast” course. I wish this course were always a part of meals! The fresh goat’s milk cheese came with local beets in a variety of styles: roasted, macerated, raw, and most creatively, sorbet. Who knew that beets could be so interesting? The soft and mild Stracchino came with strawberries and balsamic vinegar, and could have been a dessert by itself. My favorite was the Parmigiano-Reggiano and Medjool date pairing. The dates were meaty and sweet, a perfect contrast to the salty parmesan.

He says:
And the Manchego and white anchovies were a phenomenal pairing, the smoothness of the former mitigating the intense saltiness of the latter. The cheese platters matched the appetizers in their execution and surpassed them for their innovation.

She says:
And then dessert. Ahhh… I had the warm Valrhona chocolate cake, which is pure chocolate decadence. Molten chocolate cake is a great dessert for restaurants to serve, as it seems impressively difficult and is deliciously rich. However, knowing how simple it is to make (and easily improved by using high quality chocolate) I wouldn’t give this one my top vote (although I will pick up their pairing of mint ice cream). In terms of pure deliciousness, the winner was the banana cream pie. It was neither heavy nor overly sweet, with a fairly dominant banana flavor. And the cornmeal crust was of perfect consistency… similar to the crumbliness of a graham-cracker crust, but less sweet and buttery. My least favorite was Downtown Boy’s dessert.

He says:
Hey, I really liked my orange creamsicle panna cotta! Perhaps you need to be a true popsicle fan to enjoy this novel take on a Good Humor favorite. The two-tiered egg custard had a cream bottom layer and a bright orange top… it really did taste like a creamsicle. The poached rhubarb on the side added some bite to this offbeat dessert. My father’s chipotle chocolate pecan tart was the most creative dessert of the night. The attack was sweet but the finish quite spicy as the pepper kicked in, a complex trick that left our mouths buzzing.

She says:
Of course, this wasn’t the end of the meal. Following dessert, the waiter dropped off a sampling of cookies and truffles from the pastry chef. And even as we walked out of the restaurant, the attached bakery handed us a couple of small bags of cookies for the road.

He says:
And this is on top of all the palette cleansers delivered between each course, each one better than most entrées in any other restaurant. My favorite was the asparagus soup. It was cool and refreshing, the light notes of asparagus carefully distilled and accented with a touch of crème fraiche. Delicious.

We say:
Bacchanalia is the real deal. It rises above the culinary clutter of the Atlanta restaurant scene to provide a true fine-dining experience. Until further notice, it deserves the title “Best Restaurant in Atlanta.”




Update: December 2008


She says:
Second time around for Downtown Boy and me, and it’s just as fantabulous. The appetizers are probably Bacchanalia’s strongest suit… I was dying to order the Gulf crab fritter again (still on the menu!) but instead I chose the potato gnocchi. The dish was uber creamy and delicious, the gnocchi was tender without being gummy and adorned with a pile of delicate chanterelle mushrooms.

He says:
I too was tempted by the crab fritter, but eventually decided to go for the veal sweetbreads. Served atop a bed of lentils, the gaminess of the veal liver came through in robust, unctuous notes. The sweetbreads could have been softer though, as I suspected they were slightly overcooked.

She says:
Remembering Bacchanalia’s forte for fish, we split the Gulf Red Snapper entrée and the Nantucket Bay scallops. The small bay scallops were wonderful – mildly sweet, tender, the tops seared and salty enough to perfectly compliment the sweetness. Unlike other entrees, the sides weren’t much to speak of… a few slivers of carrots didn’t add much.

As for the snapper, I was very disappointed in this dish -- it was really dry and tasted cheap. I let Downtown Boy eat most of my portion.

He says:
I didn’t have a major problem with the snapper, but I agree with Uptown Girl that this dish was unremarkable. It was prepared simply to let the fish do to the talking, but it lacked any genuine flavor. Alas, it appears Bacchanalia doesn’t do everything perfectly!

For the cheese and contrast platter, I had a wonderful pairing of pears, Point Reyes blue cheese, and candied walnuts. The marvel of this dish is that I don’t care for any of these ingredients by themselves, but when taken together the resulting combination is a playful swirl of sweet, salty, creamy, and refreshing notes. Terrific!

She says:
I went with the dates and parmigiano-reggiano, which I loved on our previous visit.

As for dessert I chose the chipotle sweet potato fried pie, which was as interesting as it sounds. Little wonton-like pastries were filled with pureed sweet potato and served with a sprinkling of spicy chipotle. I’m not sold on sweet potato as a pie filling – it wasn’t sweet enough, for one – but the pastry was wonderful, with a lightness that reminded me of a sopapilla. Mexican chocolate ice cream and toasted meringue (aka marshmallow) sat on the side, which added some of the missing sweetness from the potato.

He says:
I wanted to see what Bacchanalia could do with a pistachio pear butter tart, and they didn’t disappoint. The overwhelming “butteriness” of the crust was this dessert’s main highlight, which served to accentuate the brown sugar crumbles and the soft, fresh pears within. It’s easily one of the best tarts I’ve ever had.

We say:
While the breathtaking magic that comes with eating at Bacchanalia for the first time has ebbed somewhat, this restaurant still operates at a level that few other Atlanta eateries can match. The city’s best restaurant in 2007, it retains that crown in 2008.





Bacchanalia

1198 Howell Mill Road, Atlanta, GA 30318
http://www.starprovisions.com/

Thursday, November 13, 2008

CAKES & ALE

He says:
At Cakes & Ale, simplicity rules. It starts with the décor – solid white walls lined with mirrors and illustrations drawn from culinary textbooks. REM’s Automatic for the People softly plays in the background. The waiters wear black. Specials are written on a chalkboard like in an English pub. Nothing fancy. Nothing outrageous. If Cakes & Ale wants your attention, they want the food to do the talking.

She says:
And boy did it speak to me! Our enthusiastic waiter made every item on the menu sound amazing (or “really cool” in his words), so it was a tough choice. I ended up selecting the pompano (a type of fish, related to mackerel), and a helluva fish it was. It was cooked “en papillote,” or baked in a pouch, which ensured the delicate fish stayed moist and tender. Thinly sliced onions and peppers were draped on top, adding a touch of piquancy, but overall the fresh flavor of the fish stood on its own. It came with a side of potato-butternut squash puree. The slight sweetness of the squash combined with a generous amount of butter made this side irresistible. And mixed with a bite of the fish… absolute perfection! This is one of the best entrees I have eaten in Atlanta.

He says:
Cakes & Ale’s chicken pot pie is a glorious example of restraint. Some eateries, like The Lady & Sons, feel the need to radically alter this classic comfort food. But why mess with perfection? Cakes & Ale’s version is a simple pie baked in a ceramic dish that bests Swanson’s TV dinner classic at every turn with fresher ingredients and superior taste. The crust is flaky and buttery. Copious chunks of plump chicken breast swim with corn and beans in a thick, golden broth. It may look rather plain, but it’s the best chicken pot pie I’ve ever had.

She says:
For dessert we shared the pomegranate flan, which consisted of a layer of flan topped by a thick layer of pomegranate jelly and a sprinkling of pomegranate seeds. The flavor was wonderful, not too sweet with the tangy, berry-like flavor of the pomegranate shining through. I didn’t particularly like the texture, though; the creaminess of the flan was overwhelmed by the heaviness of the jelly.

He says:
So picky! I loved the flan exactly the way it was.

We say:
This just might be our favorite small restaurant in town.




Cakes & Ale Restaurant

254 W. Ponce de Leon Avenue, Decatur, GA 30030
http://www.cakesandalerestaurant.com/

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

BAY LEAVES


She says:
I don’t think the future is bright for Bay Leaves. We visited on a Thursday evening with a Creative Loafing coupon in hand and ended up being the only ones there during our entire meal. This doesn’t bode well for the Little Five eatery, which only opened in May. I can’t say that I will feel any great loss if the restaurant ends up closing, but there may be some disappointed vegetarians out there, if only because their options are few and far between in this meat-loving town.

Bay Leaves’ menu focuses largely on vegetarian items and meat that comes from local, organic animals. (There’s also quite a few fish choices, but I forgot to see if they were sustainable options.) As for the cuisine itself… I’m not sure what’s going on. The menu is supposedly “international fusion” but seems to be primarily a mélange of Thai and American – an odd combination, particularly in a city so laden with good Thai food. Downtown Boy and I agree that a chef should pick one cuisine and do it well, rather than try to please the masses with multiple cuisines.

Our meal started off well, with the Bay Leaves’ Volcano appetizer, which consisted of pita bread topped with sautéed mushrooms, basil, spinach, tomatoes, and fake meat. A drizzle of creamy, chipotle dressing brought it all together. It’s not rocket-science but it tasted good.

He says:
The fish sandwich I ordered was one of the sadder things I’ve seen in Atlanta. The grilled tilapia was passable, but what happened to the “pesto dressing” the menu mentioned? My sandwich only came with lettuce and tomatoes. And where was the “fresh ciabatta bread”? The tiny fillet of tilapia came between 2 slices of supermarket brown bread – and not the nice Pepperidge Farm 7-Grain bread, but the cheap, Home Pride 99-cent stuff.

Seriously, if I want to eat a sandwich like this I’d rather stay home and throw a can of sardines on Wonder Bread. The dish’s saving grace was the sweet potato fries, which were nice and crunchy.

She says:
On our very sweet waitress’s recommendation, I got the ginger chicken. I was eager to back Bay Leaves’ support of all-natural, wholesome, happy chickens, but the chunks of chicken didn’t taste very happy. In fact, they were a little dry. The chicken had been sautéed in soy sauce with bell peppers and LOTS of shredded ginger. The ginger was everywhere and could have used a lot more dicing. Overall, the dish was overwhelmingly gingery and easily something I could make at home.

He says:
For dessert we tried the fried ice cream, two large scoops of vanilla with a thick, doughy crust. The fried exterior was far thicker than I’ve seen in other restaurants, but I didn’t mind since deep-fried anything tends to be A-OK in my book.

She says:
I thought it was terrible. The fried dough on the outside was too thick and tasted slightly of rancid oil.

We say:
While we support Bay Leaves’ use of natural ingredients, we definitely do not support their mediocre cooking.





Bay Leaves

1138 Euclid Avenue, Atlanta GA 30307
http://www.rewardsnetwork.com/details.htm?merchantId=91891

Thursday, June 5, 2008

BUCKHEAD DINER

He says:
For several years now I’ve been obsessed with the whole “high/low” craze. Hoodie-blazers? Awesome. Mac & cheese made with gruyere and white truffle oil? I’ll take it! So when I first heard of the oxymoronic Buckhead Diner (Buckhead = high-class, Diner = low-class … get it?!) I knew Uptown Girl and I would inevitably make an appearance at this Atlanta stalwart.

Located right off Piedmont Road, the Buckhead Diner does its best imitation of a 1950’s diner. Counter seats overlook the open grill and spacious booths are pressed against every wall. The overall décor is a subtle Art Deco. But there are touches of upper-crust modernity throughout as well. The tables are a rich mahogany and the booths are upholstered with buttery-soft leather. There is the valet, who insists on taking your car even though there are plenty of open spots in the parking lot. And then there is, of course, the menu.

She says:
You can order a burger & fries off this extensive menu as easily as you can select the mahi mahi tostada. As Downtown Boy said, Buckhead is all about mixing the high and the low. Luckily, our choices were made easy by the $30 prix-fixe menu (we visited during Buckhead Restaurant Week).

To start, I had the chevril scented crab cake, which came with your typical butter sauce. It was average… I’ve had yummier versions with fresher and sweeter crab, but I’ve also had ones that tasted like the nasty dredges of the ocean floor.

I also tried the Truffled Chicken Salad. It tasted like ordinary chicken salad on a bed of lettuce. Wah-wah.

He says:
I don’t usually wax poetic about salads, but Buckhead Diner’s beef sirloin carpaccio arugula salad must be singled out for praise. This “salad” consisted of fresh spring greens garnished with six strips of sirloin steak. Most fine-dining establishments barely give you that much in their entrees, but Buckhead Diner tossed the medium-rare cuts into the salad like so many grape tomatoes. The beef was juicy and complemented the greens better than I could have imagined – it was totally a Downtown Boy dish!

The soft-shelled crab also hit the spot. Deep fried into a golden-brown perfection, the crab was briny and crunchy in all the right ways.

She says:
After my two average starters, the entrée I ordered finally dressed to impress. The scallops were some of the best I’ve had outside of the Pacific Northwest, seared nicely on the top and bottom, and tender within. They came atop a delicious bed of vegetable risotto, and I almost never like risotto! It was cooked through without displaying the slightest bit of mushiness. At the bottom of the bowl was a puree of peas, which was disgustingly salty, but certainly made the dish look beautiful.

He says:
I was starving, so I opted for the meat and potatoes entrée: Flat Iron Steak and Mashed Potatoes. It was ho-hum. The steak was dry compared to the lovely steak strips in my salad, which makes me wonder how a restaurant can knock one dish out of the park and then completely whiff on another? The lump of potatoes on the side were nothing special.

For dessert we split a crème brulee with chocolate chunks, which we both hated. The crème brulee itself was more gummy than creamy. It also didn’t jive with the chocolate bits buried at the bottom of the dish. Worst of all, the pastry chef used milk chocolate rather than dark, which would have offset the crème brulee’s sweetness.

We say:
Buckhead Diner is a fun choice for upscale eats with a downtown look. But there are as many hits as misses on the menu, so choose carefully.




Buckhead Diner
3073 Piedmont Rd NE, Atlanta, GA 30305
www.buckheadrestaurants.com/diner.html

Thursday, May 15, 2008

SHAUN'S

He says:
After nearly two years of eating out in Atlanta, Bacchanalia remains the best restaurant in the city by a wide margin. The #2 position is still up for grabs, though, with Rathbun’s and Cuerno jockeying for the lead.

Enter a new contender, and a formidable one at that.

Shaun’s occupies a simple, almost quaint space in the heart of Inman Park. In contrast to several other fine dining establishments in Atlanta, Shaun’s eschews glitzy décor and sardine-like seating for hardwood floors, white walls, and ample room for intimate conversation. Chef/owner Shaun Doty wisely understands that a truly good restaurant allows the food, and not the mood lighting, to do the talking.

She says:
We had received a recommendation to try the chopped liver appetizer, which according to the menu, was prepared “east village style.” I have no idea what that means… perhaps it means chicken salad, because that is exactly what the appetizer tasted like – chicken salad on toast. There was the additional flavor of the liver, but even in a gourmet restaurant, liver still doesn’t taste good to me.

In contrast, the Maryland style jumbo lump crab cake was phenomenal. It was exactly how a crab cake should be: heavy on the crab, light on the filler, with the slightest crunch on the exterior. The crab was extremely fresh, and it was served with a Dijon mustard sauce that added a hint of spiciness.

He says:
For my main course I selected the chicken liver fettuccini, which is a steal at $14 (though this isn’t reflective of other prices on the menu). I have a love/hate relationship with liver, but in this case I loved it. I’ve honestly never had a pasta dish like this. The organic, free-range livers were lightly seared for an exquisite crunch, and they lent the pasta a remarkable unctuousness. Meanwhile the fettuccine had been steeped in a mild and slightly sweet marsala wine sauce that wisely allowed the richness of the chicken livers to hold the spotlight. This is not a dish you can eat every evening – you’d probably die of a heart attack by Day 4 – but for full-bodied flavor it’s tough to beat.

She says:
Talk about rich! I couldn’t handle more than one bite of that fettuccini!

I went with something a bit lighter – Georgia trout served with capers and a touch of lemon. Unfortunately, the fish wasn’t fried, which is what usually gives the flavor-filled trout skin that delicious crispiness. It was still good, as were the fresh greens that came with, but I wasn’t overly impressed with my dish.

He says:
I ended the meal with the cheesecake flan, the bastard child of two dessert menu stalwarts. It comes in a typical flan shape with an accompanying apricot sauce, but the flavor is 100% cheesecake. The texture splits the difference, skipping the custard consistency of flan for a liquid mouthfeel that’s not quite cheesecake. Like I said, it’s a bastard, but at least it’s an interesting one.

She says:
I couldn’t resist ordering the chocolate tart. It’s your typical dense chocolate ganache that almost hurts it’s so chocolatey. It definitely put me over the top, but with Downtown Boy in a chicken liver coma, I wasn’t the only one waddling out of the restaurant.

One thing that needs work at Shaun’s is the service. Our waiter didn’t even pretend to know a thing about the wine list… his advice: “Well, usually I recommend white wine with fish, and red with everything else.” Wow, now that’s useful. Other things fell apart too. The entrees arrived while we were still feasting on the appetizers; my leftovers didn’t make it back to the table until I had asked two different servers.

We say:

Despite a few hiccups, Shaun’s is a strong candidate for the 2nd best dining in Atlanta.




Shaun’s
1029 Edgewood Avenue NE Atlanta, GA 30307
http://www.shaunsrestaurant.com/

Sunday, March 30, 2008

MURPHY'S

He says:
For Uptown Girl and me, Murphy’s always seems to be Plan B. For example, we might have coupons to eat at American Roadhouse just up the street, but it happens to be closed. What do we do? We go to Murphy’s. Or we’re excited for tapas at Noche, but the Friday night crowd is piled out into the street. What do we do? We go to Murphy’s. You get the idea.

According to their website, Murphy’s "fuses fresh local and international ingredients to create a new genre of American cuisine," but it's really just a generically competent eatery with a prime location in Virginia Highlands. Frankly, it’s hard to get excited about a restaurant where fried calamari and meatloaf are the most daring items on the menu. To their credit, the staff at Murphy’s always seems happy to see you, and they can often find you a great seat right away.

This restaurant also happens to serve some of the best pre-meal bread around. The sourdough slices have a hot, soft interior with a wonderfully crunchy crust, and they come with a robust olive oil for dipping. I’m a total sucker for details like this.

She says:
For appetizers, we tried the cod croquets and the crabcakes, neither of which I thought were very impressive. The croquets – delicately fried chunks of cod and potato – were on the bland side, although others in our party seemed to like them quite a bit (including Downtown Boy). In my opinion, the only saving grace was the zingy tomatillo-avocado sauce that came with the croquets. As for the crabcakes, they tasted fresh, but the celery flavor unfortunately overwhelmed the crab.

He says:
The rainbow trout I ordered was a genuine surprise, mostly because I got two seriously huge fillets of it – you’ve got to love Southern portions! Better still was that it was delicious. The trout’s skin had been wisely left on and seared, giving this white fish both crispiness and a bold flavor. Even if the accompanying wild rice is completely flavorless, at $17 this is one of the true bargains on Murphy’s overpriced menu.

She says:
On the other hand, the all natural herb-roasted chicken wasn’t much of a surprise. It’s rare to find really good chicken in a restaurant. As with most places, Murphy’s “free bird” had juicy dark meat and dried-out breast meat. The roasted autumn root vegetables that came with it tasted great, although they made the entire dish feel out of season (autumn vegetables in March?). The exception was the potatoes, which were the blandest, starchiest things I’ve ever had. Thank god for the sweet potatoes and new carrots.

The one thing that Murphy’s does right is dessert, and specifically, the Tollhouse Pie. With an Oreo cookie and walnut crust, chewy chocolate filling, and a big scoop of vanilla ice cream on top, this pie is part chocolate chip cookie, part brownie, and totally delicious. It’s good enough to make Murphy’s Plan A.

We say:
Murphy’s is boring food done right!



Murphy’s
997 Virginia Avenue NE, Atlanta GA 30306
http://www.murphysvh.com/home.html

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

RATHBUN'S

She says:
If you’ve never seen Rathbun’s before, it’s understandable. Along with Kevin Rathbun’s two other businesses (Krog Bar and Kevin Rathbun Steak), it occupies a former stove factory on a dark graffitied street in Inman Park that you’d never just stumble upon.

If you’ve never heard of Rathbun’s before, well that’s another story. Creative Loafing readers rated Kevin Rathbun Atlanta’s “best chef” in 2007, and Esquire named Rathbun’s as one of the Top 21 New Restaurants when it opened in 2004. And just last month, Kevin and his brother defeated Bobby Flay on “Iron Chef America.” How much more famous can you get?

Needless to say, we entered Rathbun’s with high expectations. Exposed brick walls and warehouse-high ceilings set the scene as we perused the lengthy menu. There were numerous mouth-watering fish and seafood options to choose from, as well as a heavy emphasis on red meat. Red meat seems to be a particular passion of the chef’s, making up most of the “Second Mortgage” section of the menu, which can only refer to how much debt you’re going to be in after you pay for your meal! The waitress gave us plenty of time to look over the menu. Actually, I think she just forgot about us. She certainly forgot about the glass of wine I ordered until Downtown Boy reminded her.

He says:
The mediocre service aside, our Rathbun’s dining experience started off on the right foot with an excellent crab tart. It consisted of sweet crabmeat mixed with Creole mustard and served in a pastry tart crust; a smear of sweet pepper ketchup provided a zingy contrast. In the hands of a lesser chef, the creamy mustard and buttery crust might have drowned out the crab’s remarkable freshness, but instead they heightened its flavor. With an appetizer like this, we couldn’t wait to see what entrees Kevin Rathbun could whip out.

She says:
The Carolina Mountain Red trout was perfect. Fried with the skin on, the flavor was outstanding – as if it had been pulled from a stream minutes before. It was drizzled with a teriyaki-type sauce, which was unnecessary and distracting, but a puddle of ponzu hollandaise did add a nice creaminess to the dish. The fish came with stir-fried broccoli which was WAY too salty.

He says:
Judging from the success of his steakhouse (and his Iron Chef victory using elk) Kevin Rathbun knows red meat, and I was eager to see what he could do with my Second Mortgage platter. The venison I ordered was, unfortunately, a letdown. The fist-sized shank tasted like filet mignon in its preparation and juiciness, with just a slight gaminess to differentiate it from its bovine cousin. But for $46 (an extravagant price by Atlanta’s standards) I expected a truly magnificent dish, and this one was simply ordinary. The meat came with a rubbery fennel bulb that I left untouched. Fortunately, my side-order of mashed potatoes was delightfully buttery and smooth. Uptown Girl and I scraped the serving bowl clean.

She says:
The best value at Rathbun’s is the dessert: for $11, you can sample 4 desserts from an extensive menu. Since desserts in most fine restaurants are usually around $8 for a conservative serving, for $11 I was expecting four tiny bites. But the desserts were decently sized – more than we could finish after our meaty entrees. My favorite was the chocolate cupcake with chocolate ganache. The cake reminded me of my mom’s own delicious homemade cakes, and the dark chocolate frosting was decadently bittersweet. I didn’t love the banana peanut butter cream pie. With what tasted like toasted marshmallow on top, it was far too sweet, and it was otherwise a little simplistic – for example, the peanut butter aspect of the pie was literally a thick layer of peanut butter spread onto the meager flake that constituted the crust.

He says:

My favorite was the dark chocolate brownie with dulce de leche filling and coffee ice cream; it tasted as good it sounds. The gooey toffee cake with Jack Daniel’s ice cream had potential, but the cake’s sponginess lent the dessert an odd texture.

We say:
If you are thinking about taking out a second mortgage, Rathbun’s is certainly worth a visit – it is, overall, an excellent restaurant. Just be warned that the pricier dishes do not always pan out. Oh, and whatever you do, don’t leave without dessert.




Rathbun’s

112 Krog St NE, Atlanta, GA 30307
http://www.rathbunsrestaurant.com/